The Interactive Poetry Pages

Aha! Poetry


Show authors for all the poetry lines.
Aha! Poetry Top Page
Poem Number 22648
The Tale of Gary Dean


Commentary:
Gary was sound asleep,
slumped, in a hard wooden chair
at the dinner table.
`
It amazes me
how this weathered man can fall
asleep anywhere.
`
He awoke to a
watery Manhattan and
the sound of static.

-------
This is what i like...
asleep/slumped;
amazes/me/man;
and then to recaptitulate,sleep.
rhyme: chair/anywhere.
assonance: awoke/watery;
as well as: manhattan and,
and then the sneaky "sounds
of static".
this is true poetry.
spare, lean, and yet descriptive.
writing for readers,
and rembering the language.
Reminds a bit
of Carver, a bit of Eliot.
Not bad company.
You got it right! Now keep it going.
Do it again.
i love this...fallon
-------
a couple of editiorial critics:
the verb tenses need to agree.
should you say that gary was, or
gary is? i like the latter.
this is probably the best poem
that i have seen in a long, long,
time.
agree with me or not:
we should all asprire to this
paucity of words and richness
of image and meaning...fallon

-------
Gary is sound asleep,
slumped, in a hard wooden chair
at the dinner table.
`
It amazes me
how this weathered man can fall
asleep anywhere.
`
He awoke to a
watery Manhattan and
the sound of static.
`
There we are Mr. Fallon. I do think that using "is" is well, more appropriate. I believe the verbs tense agrees now, and now it reads better. Good eye. -Jesse

-------
Jesse. as much as i liked it before: with that little change, it reads so much better. Bravo...~f
Add to commentary


Unless specifically noted otherwise, copyrights for all lines entered belong to the authors only.
Show authors for all the poetry lines.
Return to current poems in progress.
Completed Poems.
Aha! Poetry Top Page
Send a general comment to the web author, or view some of the comments left by others.
Thanks in advance for any feedback you can pass on.
Disruption report - Please choose this link to report any disruptive or offensive entries, or closing sprees, if they appear. Thank you.

Brought to you by Ann Cantelow.